Questions: Which of these sentences has the best word order for clearest meaning? A man rode with a red shirt the horse. A man rode the horse with a red shirt. A man with a red shirt rode the horse.

Which of these sentences has the best word order for clearest meaning?
A man rode with a red shirt the horse.
A man rode the horse with a red shirt.
A man with a red shirt rode the horse.
Transcript text: Which of these sentences has the best word order for clearest meaning? A man rode with a red shirt the horse. A man rode the horse with a red shirt. A man with a red shirt rode the horse.
failed

Solution

failed
failed

The answer is: A man with a red shirt rode the horse.

Explanation for each option:

  1. A man rode with a red shirt the horse.

    • This sentence is awkward and confusing because the phrase "with a red shirt" is misplaced. It disrupts the natural flow of the sentence and makes it unclear whether the man or the horse is associated with the red shirt.
  2. A man rode the horse with a red shirt.

    • This sentence is clearer than the first one but still ambiguous. It could be interpreted as the horse wearing the red shirt, which is not the intended meaning.
  3. A man with a red shirt rode the horse.

    • This sentence has the clearest meaning. It clearly indicates that the man is the one wearing the red shirt and that he is the one riding the horse. The phrase "with a red shirt" is correctly placed next to "a man," making the sentence easy to understand.
Was this solution helpful?
failed
Unhelpful
failed
Helpful