Questions: Conflict Two: Choosing to Comfort Gabriel with a Warmth Memory Choices Jonas Made: Before During After

To address the question regarding the conflict of Jonas choosing to comfort Gabriel with a warmth memory, we need to consider the context and character development in Lois Lowry's novel "The Giver." This novel explores themes of memory, emotion, and individuality within a highly controlled society.

1. Before:

   • Thought Process: Before Jonas decides to comfort Gabriel with a warmth memory, he is aware of the strict rules governing the sharing of memories. As the Receiver of Memory, Jonas is entrusted with the community's memories, which are meant to be kept from others to maintain societal stability. However, Jonas has developed a bond with Gabriel, a baby who is struggling to sleep and thrive. Jonas's empathy and growing understanding of emotions lead him to consider breaking the rules to help Gabriel.

2. During:

   • Thought Process: During the moment when Jonas decides to share a memory with Gabriel, he is driven by compassion and a sense of responsibility. He understands that Gabriel is suffering and that the warmth of a memory could provide comfort and security. Jonas's decision is influenced by his growing disillusionment with the community's suppression of emotions and his desire to protect and nurture Gabriel.

3. After:

   • Thought Process: After sharing the memory, Jonas experiences a mix of emotions. He feels a sense of fulfillment and relief in having helped Gabriel, but he is also aware of the potential consequences of his actions. Jonas's decision to share the memory marks a turning point in his character development, as he begins to question the community's rules more deeply and considers the value of emotions and memories in human experience.

Jonas's decision to comfort Gabriel with a warmth memory highlights the central conflict between individuality and societal conformity in "The Giver." It illustrates Jonas's growing awareness of the importance of emotions and personal connections, challenging the community's rigid control over its citizens. This act of defiance is a pivotal moment in the narrative, setting the stage for Jonas's eventual decision to seek a life beyond the confines of the community.