Questions: (b) Suppose the following situation occurred. Isabel didn't put money into a savings account each month. When summertime came, Isabel was able to take a vacation.
Complete the table to determine the truth of Isabel's mom's statement in this situation. Use T for true and F for false. You may add more columns, bu those added columns will not be graded.
Transcript text: (b) Suppose the following situation occurred. Isabel didn't put money into a savings account each month. When summertime came, Isabel was able to take a vacation.
Complete the table to determine the truth of Isabel's mom's statement in this situation. Use T for true and F for false. You may add more columns, bu those added columns will not be graded.
Solution
Solution Steps
Step 1: Define the propositions
Let _p_ be the proposition "Isabel put money into a savings account each month."
Let _q_ be the proposition "Isabel was able to take a vacation."
The given statement in the problem says that Isabel _didn't_ put money into her savings account and she _was_ able to take a vacation. Thus, _p_ is false and _q_ is true.
Step 2: Evaluate ~p and ~q
~p represents "not p", meaning Isabel did _not_ put money into a savings account each month. Since _p_ is false, ~p is true.
~q represents "not q", meaning Isabel was _not_ able to take a vacation. Since _q_ is true, ~q is false.
Step 3: Evaluate ~p → ~q
~p → ~q is the conditional statement "If not p, then not q". This translates to "If Isabel did not put money into a savings account each month, then she was not able to take a vacation." We know ~p is true and ~q is false. A conditional statement is only false when the hypothesis is true and the conclusion is false. Therefore, ~p → ~q is false.
Final Answer:
| _p_ | _q_ | ~_p_ | ~_q_ | ~_p_ → ~_q_ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | T | T | F | F |