Questions: 4. In each case, a student is holding a nearly massless wooden stick horizontally. Each stick has one mass attached at the halfway mark and another mass at the far-end of the stick. The sticks are identical, and the specific values and locations are given in the figures. Is the magnitude of the torque exerted by the student greater in Case A, greater in Case B, or the same in both cases? Explain your reasoning.
Transcript text: 4. In each case, a student is holding a nearly massless wooden stick horizontally. Each stick has one mass attached at the halfway mark and another mass at the far-end of the stick. The sticks are identical, and the specific values and locations are given in the figures. Is the magnitude of the torque exerted by the student greater in Case A, greater in Case B, or the same in both cases? Explain your reasoning.
Solution
Solution Steps
Step 1: Analyze the forces and distances
In both cases, the system is in equilibrium. This means the net torque is zero. The torques involved are the torque exerted by the student and the torque due to the weights. The torque due to the weights is equal and opposite to the torque exerted by the student.
Step 2: Calculate the torque due to the weights in Case A
In Case A, the torque due to the weights is (0.5 kg * g * L/2) + (1 kg * g * L) = 1.25 * g * L/2. Where _g_ is the acceleration due to gravity, and L is the length of the stick.
Step 3: Calculate the torque due to the weights in Case B
In Case B, the torque due to the weights is (1 kg * g * L/2) + (0.5 kg * g * L) = 1.25 * g * L/2.
Final Answer
The magnitude of the torque exerted by the student is the same in both cases. Even though the masses are switched, the total torque they exert is identical because the sum of the products of force times distance from the hand is the same.