Questions: Alice and Andrew are discussing thesis development. Alice argues that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about the topic. Andrew, on the other hand, maintains that a topic is not a thesis but that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. Who is correct? Alice is correct. Andrew is correct. Neither Alice nor Andrew is correct. Both are partially correct.

Both are partially correct.

Alice and Andrew are discussing the relationship between a topic and a thesis, and both have valid points, though they are not entirely correct in their individual assertions.

Alice argues that a topic becomes a thesis if we want to write about it. This perspective highlights the idea that a thesis is derived from a topic. In academic writing, a topic is indeed the starting point, and a thesis statement is developed from it. However, simply wanting to write about a topic does not automatically make it a thesis. A thesis requires a specific argument or claim about the topic.

Andrew maintains that a topic is not a thesis but that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. This view emphasizes that a thesis is a specific statement or argument that provides direction and focus for writing about a topic. While it is true that a thesis is foundational to developing a coherent argument, it is not accurate to say that a thesis is the foundation of a topic. Instead, a thesis is developed from a topic.

In summary, both Alice and Andrew touch on important aspects of thesis development, but neither fully captures the complete relationship between a topic and a thesis. A topic is the broad subject area, while a thesis is a specific claim or argument about that topic.